What's New?
 - Sitemap - Calendar
Trade Agreements - FTAA Process - Trade Issues 

español - français - português
Search


BINATIONAL PANEL REVIEW PURSUANT TO
ARTICLE 1904 OF
NORTH AMERICAN FREE TRADE AGREEMENT

 

In the matter of: Magnesium From Canada (Injury)
Full Sunset Review of Antidumping Duty and Countervailing Duty Orders

Secretariat File No.:
USA-CDA-00-1904-09
 
   

Decision of the Panel

July 16, 2002


BEFORE:

 
Matthew A. Gold, Chairman  
Alan S. Alexandroff  
W. Roy Hines  
E. Neil McKelvey  
Morton Pomeranz  

Appearances:  
On behalf of the Gouvernement du Québec:  
Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker, LLP
(Hamilton Loeb, A. Jeff Ifrah, and Chris Cloutier)
 
   
On behalf of the United States International Trade Commission:  
Office of the General Counsel ,U.S. International Trade Commission
(Andrea C. Casson)
 
   
On behalf of the Magnesium Corporation of America:  
King & Spalding
(Joseph W. Dorn, Stephen A. Jones, and Dean Pinkert)
 
   


Table of Contents

I.     Introduction
II.    Background
III.   Jurisdiction
IV.  Applicable Law
V.  Standard Of Review
VI.  Inclusion Of Magnola’s Prospective Exports To The United
A. Background
B. Inclusion of Magnola’s Prospective Exports to the United States
    1. Prospective New Exporter
      2. Nature of Subsidy
VII. Construction Of “Likely”
VIII.Attribution
  A. Requirement of Attribution Analysis
      1. Attribution in Sunset Reviews
      2. Non-Substitutability Finding
      a. Evidence Supporting Non-Substitutability
    b. Evidence Detracting from Non-Substitutability
      3. Facts of Gerald Metals
  B. Absence of Attribution Analysis
IX.  Volume And Price Effects
  A. Alloy Magnesium
B. Pure Magnesium
X.   Disposition and Order
 


Back to Top