SICE-Dispute Settlement-NAFTA/USA-CDA-00-1904-09

BINATIONAL PANEL REVIEW PURSUANT TO
ARTICLE 1904 OF
NORTH AMERICAN FREE TRADE AGREEMENT

In the matter of: Magnesium From Canada (Injury) Full Sunset Review of Antidumping Duty and Countervailing Duty Orders	Secretariat File No.: USA-CDA-00-1904-09

Decision of the Panel

July 16, 2002

Appearances:
On behalf of the Gouvernement du Qu�bec:
Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker, LLP (Hamilton Loeb, A. Jeff Ifrah, and Chris Cloutier)

On behalf of the United States International Trade Commission:
Office of the General Counsel ,U.S. International Trade Commission (Andrea C. Casson)

On behalf of the Magnesium Corporation of America:
King & Spalding (Joseph W. Dorn, Stephen A. Jones, and Dean Pinkert)

Table of Contents

I. Introduction
II. Background
III. Jurisdiction
IV. Applicable Law
V. Standard Of Review
VI. Inclusion Of Magnola�s Prospective Exports To The United
	A. Background
	B. Inclusion of Magnola�s Prospective Exports to the United States
	1. Prospective New Exporter
	2. Nature of Subsidy
VII. Construction Of �Likely�
VIII.Attribution
	A. Requirement of Attribution Analysis
	1. Attribution in Sunset Reviews
	2. Non-Substitutability Finding
		a. Evidence Supporting Non-Substitutability
		b. Evidence Detracting from Non-Substitutability
	3. Facts of Gerald Metals
	B. Absence of Attribution Analysis
IX. Volume And Price Effects
	A. Alloy Magnesium
	B. Pure Magnesium
X. Disposition and Order

	What's New? - Sitemap - Calendar Trade Agreements - FTAA Process - Trade Issues	espa�ol - fran�ais - portugu�s
		Search